Recent reading
Jan. 3rd, 2024 08:51 pmUnrelated to the rest of the post, today I have learned the word "anasyrma" and am delighted with it.
A Wizard of Earthsea and The Tombs of Atuan by Ursula K Le Guin (1968 and 1971)
Yuletide canon review. It's been quite some time since I read these, and I much enjoyed the reread. Damn, but Le Guin could write! This is not news, I know, but it does very much strike you when you're trying to write fic for one of her books. I can really see why she revisited them later for reasons of feminism, though--I'm not sure how she could be so thoughtful about POC in Earthsea, and at the same time having women be so invisible: women who are mentioned casually are only ever the wives of men having professions, and don't professions of their own, and when women have larger roles, they are most often evil or unwittingly serve evil. I mean, yes, The Tombs of Atuan very much do pass the Bechdel test, but see: unwittingly serving evil, and having a man come in and release Tenar from that. Nevertheless, I do love these books! The worldbuilding is so vivid, and the first book is such a great story of coming of age and such a good twist on the "defeating the evil antagonist" trope. Also, there's such a sense of a rich past, too. I do respect the later books, but also I do kind of wish that (like Tolkien) she had filled in the stories of Morred and Elfarran and Erreth-Akbe...
I was talking to my beta reader
cahn about the style of these books compared to her later ones, and
cahn was saying that the Earthsea books are doing the high fantasy thing and that's why the style is more elaborate than her later books. I'm not so sure, though: if you look at The Left Hand of Darkness, which is written about the same time, it hasn't got a simpler style that I can see. I wonder if this is just part of a general trend across literature towards a simpler style, which she followed.
A Wizard of Earthsea and The Tombs of Atuan by Ursula K Le Guin (1968 and 1971)
Yuletide canon review. It's been quite some time since I read these, and I much enjoyed the reread. Damn, but Le Guin could write! This is not news, I know, but it does very much strike you when you're trying to write fic for one of her books. I can really see why she revisited them later for reasons of feminism, though--I'm not sure how she could be so thoughtful about POC in Earthsea, and at the same time having women be so invisible: women who are mentioned casually are only ever the wives of men having professions, and don't professions of their own, and when women have larger roles, they are most often evil or unwittingly serve evil. I mean, yes, The Tombs of Atuan very much do pass the Bechdel test, but see: unwittingly serving evil, and having a man come in and release Tenar from that. Nevertheless, I do love these books! The worldbuilding is so vivid, and the first book is such a great story of coming of age and such a good twist on the "defeating the evil antagonist" trope. Also, there's such a sense of a rich past, too. I do respect the later books, but also I do kind of wish that (like Tolkien) she had filled in the stories of Morred and Elfarran and Erreth-Akbe...
I was talking to my beta reader
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)
![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png)